SDSignal Desk

Common Sense Media rates ChatGPT for Teens an ‘unacceptable risk’ over missing parent alerts

· Updated · Signal Desk newsroom

Analysis of reporting by The Verge. How we work

Image: The Verge

Common Sense Media says ChatGPT for Teens fails to alert parents when it should, does not offer the right help in a crisis and still does homework. OpenAI says testing may have preceded full activation of parental controls; the group says some accounts were linked well beyond that window.

Key takeaways

  • Common Sense Media labeled ChatGPT for Teens an “unacceptable risk.”
  • It says the product fails to alert parents, mishandles crisis moments and completes homework.
  • Tom Siegel says ChatGPT should be adults-only until fixes are proven by independent testing.
  • OpenAI says testing may have happened before parental controls fully activated.
  • Common Sense says some accounts were linked well beyond the activation window and still produced no alerts.

The rating

The Verge reports that Common Sense Media, the nonprofit known for rating apps and media for children, has labeled OpenAI’s ChatGPT for Teens an “unacceptable risk.” The teen experience launched in August as a guardrailed, learning-oriented product with parental controls and safety notifications. The assessment, from the group’s Youth AI Safety Institute, says it does not alert parents when it should, does not offer the right help in a crisis and still does children’s homework.

Tom Siegel, the institute’s executive director, said a teen can spend an hour discussing self-harm without a parent receiving a single alert. Until OpenAI fixes that and proves it with independent testing, he said, ChatGPT should be adults-only. Parental controls are only as useful as the confidence they deserve; a feature that works intermittently can lead parents to stop paying attention.

The methodology dispute

OpenAI spokesperson Eric Porterfield said the testing may have mostly occurred before parental controls had fully activated on test accounts, which would mean the results cannot show whether notifications work as designed. That is a legitimate methodological point. Common Sense Media replied that it confirmed with OpenAI before testing that teen features were launched; that OpenAI only disclosed afterward that activation on newly linked accounts can take several hours; and that some test accounts had been linked well beyond that window and still produced no alerts. The group also says it shared results with OpenAI before publishing. If that account holds, the timing argument explains some misses but not all.

Even in OpenAI’s best case, a parent who links an account and is told protections are on has no way of knowing about a multi-hour lag, and a crisis does not wait for a sync. A safety system silently inactive after setup is a design issue regardless of test methodology. OpenAI says it welcomes rigorous independent evaluation.

What would resolve it

An independent retest with fully activated controls, published results and plain-language visibility into the activation status of every safety feature would address the dispute. The bar for a family product is reliable behavior in a young person’s worst hour, verified by people outside the company. The same week, OpenAI announced College Planner and study tools for teens (teen tools), and it has funded research into AI and teen development (teen research grants). AI tutors can help teenagers learn; the question is whether safety features are demonstrably reliable. More in our OpenAI coverage and regulation coverage.

Who feels it

Parents
Listed protections are not the same as verified, working alerts.
Teens
Crisis moments are where the assessment finds failures.
Schools
A credible outside rating to weigh, plus homework completion concerns.
AI companies
Teen products will be judged by independent testers.

What to watch

  1. An independent retest with fully activated controls.
  2. Changes to shorten or disclose the activation delay.
  3. Regulator or lawmaker reaction.
  4. School districts adjusting recommendations.

FAQ

What did Common Sense Media find?

That ChatGPT for Teens fails to alert parents, mishandles crises and still does homework.

What does OpenAI say?

That testing may have preceded full activation of parental controls.

How did Common Sense respond?

It says some accounts were linked well beyond the activation window and still produced no alerts.

What does the group recommend?

Adults-only use until fixes are proven by independent testing.

Read the original

Continue at the source.

The Verge

Companies: OpenAI

More on OpenAI

All OpenAI coverage →