AI · Oct 21, 2026
OpenAI on Google Cloud lets companies spend Google commitments on GPT-6, and that changes procurementMehta: expecting search traffic for free content is "not an agreement" as Chegg and Penske suits fall
· Updated · Signal Desk newsroom
Analysis of reporting by Ars Technica. How we work

Judge Amit Mehta dismissed antitrust suits from Chegg and Penske Media over Google's AI Overviews, writing that publishers' expectation of traffic in exchange for content is "simply how a general search engine works." He said he was not unsympathetic to creators but that antitrust law cannot stand in for legislation.
Key takeaways
- Chegg alleged Google scraping let Gemini recreate its educational content and cut traffic.
- Penske alleged indexed content was harvested for AI answers without an opt-out.
- Mehta wrote that an expectation of traffic is not an agreement under antitrust law.
- He said the court is not "unsympathetic" to creators whose work is repurposed without pay.
- The ruling points the compensation question toward Congress rather than the courts.
The ruling
Ars Technica reports that U.S. District Judge Amit Mehta dismissed lawsuits filed in 2025 by Chegg and Penske Media, which accused Google of antitrust violations tied to AI Overviews and related AI search features. Chegg alleged that Google's scraping allowed Gemini to recreate its educational content and drained traffic from its site. Penske Media alleged that sites indexed for search had content harvested for AI answers with no practical way to opt out.
Mehta rejected the core theory that publishers had an implicit deal with Google. An "expectation" of search traffic in exchange for free content, he wrote, is not an agreement: "It is simply how a general search engine works." He added that the court is not "unsympathetic" to publishers and creators whose work Google can "repurpose without compensation," but said antitrust law cannot substitute for legislation. A companion write-up is in our story on the dismissal of the AI Overviews suits.
Why Mehta's view carries weight
Mehta is the same judge who found Google violated antitrust law in the Justice Department's general search case and oversaw the remedies fight. That makes the dismissal notable: a court that has already found monopoly conduct in search declined to stretch that doctrine into a compensation right for content used in AI answers. The decision separates two questions, Google's dominance in search and whether AI summaries unfairly free-ride on publishers, and finds that current antitrust law addresses the first, not the second.
For publishers, the practical result is that U.S. antitrust looks like a difficult route for recovering AI-related traffic losses. Options that remain include appeals or amended complaints, copyright claims, contractual terms and action abroad, where European regulators are examining AI search and the UK has pushed for an opt-out that preserves organic search visibility.
The policy gap
Mehta effectively handed the issue to lawmakers. If AI answers can draw on the open web and return a summary while referrals decline, the rules on opt-outs and payment need to come from statute or regulation. Google has meanwhile been reported to be testing payments to publishers for AI search results, a voluntary pilot rather than a legal obligation.
The ruling gives Google legal breathing room at home while political and European pressure continues. It also sets expectations for other plaintiffs: arguments built on unfairness alone are unlikely to succeed without a recognized agreement or exclusionary conduct. More in our Google Gemini coverage and regulation coverage.
Who feels it
- Publishers and educators
- U.S. antitrust looks like a dead end for AI Overviews traffic loss absent new law.
- Legal relief at home, with EU scrutiny and a publisher-pay pilot still in play.
- Lawmakers
- The judge explicitly said the problem calls for legislation.
What to watch
- Appeals or amended complaints from Chegg or Penske.
- EU action on AI search and publisher rights.
- Whether Google's publisher payment pilot expands.
FAQ
Who sued Google?
Chegg and Penske Media, in separate 2025 suits.
Why were the suits dismissed?
Mehta found an expectation of traffic for content is not an agreement under antitrust law.
Did the judge side with Google on fairness?
No. He said he was not unsympathetic to creators but that the remedy is legislation.
Is this the same judge as the DOJ search case?
Yes, Judge Amit Mehta.
Companies: Google
More on Google
AI · Oct 14, 2026
White Circle says newer OpenAI and Google image models are easier to jailbreak than their predecessorsAI · Oct 13, 2026
After months off the frontier, Google ships Gemini 4 Argon with benchmark claims and aggressive pricingAI · Sep 22, 2026
Opus 5.5 hands risky cyber prompts to an older Claude model, and that routing is the real launch storyAI · Sep 30, 2026
The four rules in the White House AI commitment, and the missing fifth: penalties