AI · Sep 30, 2026
The four rules in the White House AI commitment, and the missing fifth: penaltiesExtracted Muse instructions show hourly-updated pages on every person in a user’s life
· Updated · Signal Desk newsroom
Analysis of reporting by WIRED. How we work

WIRED reports researcher Karan Joshi extracted Meta Muse system prompts directing the agent to maintain an hourly-refreshed page for every person in a user’s life, with sections like History, Open threads and Strengthening. Meta says it uses only user-shared or public information.
Key takeaways
- Researcher Karan Joshi extracted Muse system prompts and skill files via the normal chat interface.
- Instructions call for “a page for every person in the user’s life,” refreshed hourly.
- Pages can include Facts, History, The relationship, In common, Open threads and Strengthening.
- Meta says the files were accessible for transparency and Muse uses only user-shared or public evidence.
- Each user gets a dedicated virtual machine; memory can be wiped and services disconnected, Meta says.
What the files show
WIRED’s Lily Hay Newman and Matt Burgess report that independent researcher Karan Joshi extracted Muse system prompts and skill files through the ordinary chat interface. Among them are instructions to maintain “a page for every person in the user’s life,” refreshed hourly, covering family, partners, friends, colleagues, collaborators and people the user follows.
Those pages can grow sections such as Facts, History, The relationship, In common, Open threads and Strengthening, holding items like birthdays, resolved arguments, shared savings goals and “a reason to call.” Meta says the files were meant to be accessible for transparency and that Muse uses only evidence the user has shared or public information. Millions have downloaded the agent (No. 2 app), and many have connected banks, messages or health data.
Context versus dossiers
A useful agent needs context about the people around its user. Meta spokesperson Daniel Roberts frames it as remembering the plumber who sent an invoice or which flowers a spouse liked. Joshi’s summary is that Meta wants Muse to know users like a friend. A standing hourly profile of everyone in a person’s orbit is a different matter, especially from a company whose core business involves inferring relationships at scale.
Oxford’s Carissa Véliz describes the asymmetry: people give these systems far more than they get back, and the systems infer the rest, correctly or not. The Center for Democracy and Technology’s Miranda Bogen notes Muse leans harder into relationships than rival assistants, and that such tools solicit whole-life connectors such as email, calendar and finance rather than encouraging data minimization. Remembering a birthday is a feature; compiling “Strengthening” suggestions for every colleague from bank and message access turns ambient intimacy into infrastructure.
Controls and the people who never opted in
Meta says each user gets a dedicated virtual machine, data is not shared across agents, memory can be wiped, purchases require confirmation and audit logs exist. Those are the right kinds of controls, but they do not remove the incentive to request more access. The contacts profiled never agreed to Muse at all, which raises third-party privacy questions for regulators.
The files surfaced amid wider Muse privacy disputes over Messages access and Mac full-disk permissions (Messages dispute) and earlier concerns about the product’s design (Muse creepiness). Whether users can see and edit person pages as first-class objects, and whether regulators treat relationship dossiers as sensitive data even when built from a user’s own inbox, are open questions. More in our Meta coverage, agents coverage and regulation coverage.
Who feels it
- Muse users
- Connected accounts can feed relationship pages; audit connectors and memory.
- Privacy regulators
- A concrete artifact for consent and minimization debates, including contacts’ privacy.
- Rival agent builders
- Transparency and deletion of people-memory will separate trusted products.
What to watch
- Editable person pages in Muse’s interface.
- Regulatory interest in contact dossiers.
- How relationship memory behaves when access is revoked.
FAQ
What did the researcher find?
Muse instructions to keep an hourly-refreshed page on every person in a user’s life.
What sections can the pages include?
Facts, History, The relationship, In common, Open threads and Strengthening.
What does Meta say?
That the files were accessible for transparency and Muse uses only user-shared or public information.
Can users delete the data?
Meta says memory is wipeable and services can be disconnected.
Companies: Meta
More on Meta
AI · Sep 29, 2026
Each Dot gets its own cloud computer and browser, with approval gates for sensitive actionsAI · Oct 14, 2026
Hugging Face’s guide to running Muse Spark Open: 816B parameters, 42B active, from vLLM to llama.cppAI · Sep 22, 2026
Gebru and Bender say this summer's AI headlines faded under expert review, and the record backs part of thatAI · Oct 19, 2026
Meta replaces ad IDs with a semantic token vocabulary to sharpen recommendations