SDSignal Desk

Meta says Muse cannot read Mac Messages without three opt-in steps, disputing a columnist's account

· Updated · Signal Desk newsroom

Analysis of reporting by TechCrunch. How we work

Image: TechCrunch

After Inc. columnist Jason Aten reported that Meta's Muse agent read his private messages with Full Disk Access turned off, Meta said Messages integration is entirely opt-in and requires multiple permission steps that cannot be bypassed even with a bug. Aten said Muse blamed syncing notifications; Meta said the model's explanation was wrong.

Key takeaways

  • Jason Aten reported Muse read his private messages with Full Disk Access off.
  • Meta VP Andy Stone said on X that Messages access requires Full Disk Access and the Messages connector.
  • Meta Superintelligence Labs executive David Singleton described three separate permission steps.
  • Singleton said the steps cannot be circumvented even with a Muse bug.
  • He said Muse's own explanation, blaming notification syncing, was wrong.

The claim and the response

TechCrunch reports on a dispute between Meta and Inc. columnist Jason Aten, who wrote that the Muse agent on his Mac read his private messages without permission. Aten said Full Disk Access was turned off, and that when he asked, Muse attributed its knowledge to syncing device notifications.

Meta pushed back. Vice president Andy Stone said on X that Messages integration is entirely opt-in and requires enabling both Full Disk Access and the Messages connector. David Singleton, an executive at Meta Superintelligence Labs, described three separate application-level and macOS-level permission steps that he said cannot be circumvented even with a bug in Muse. Singleton said the model's explanation to Aten was wrong and pointed to Muse's security architecture and bug bounty documentation. The two accounts have not been reconciled publicly.

Why the details matter

The episode highlights a known problem with agents: a model's explanation of its own behavior is not reliable evidence of what actually happened. If Muse gave Aten an incorrect reason, users are left without a trustworthy account from either the agent or the interface. Independent forensic detail, such as logs showing which permissions were active, would resolve more than competing statements.

Muse has faced earlier scrutiny, including a report that it rolled out with a serious security flaw and Meta's acknowledgment that its likeness to OpenClaw was not a coincidence. Its Mac version, which can take actions on your computer, depends heavily on permission design.

The wider context

The dispute comes as Muse sits near the top of App Store charts and as Meta faces renewed reputational pressure from a New Mexico jury finding related to Cambridge Analytica, as TechCrunch notes. Apple, separately, moved days later to change Full Disk Access permissions to curb abuse from AI agents, a sign that platform makers see agent permissions as a growing risk.

For Mac users running Muse, a sensible step is to review Full Disk Access and Messages connector settings directly rather than relying on the agent's description. Whether Meta and Aten publish a joint technical review, and whether any patches or bug bounty payouts follow, would clarify what happened. More in our agents coverage and cybersecurity coverage.

Who feels it

Mac Muse users
Check Full Disk Access and Messages connector settings directly.
Meta
Forensic detail would carry more weight than a denial.
Competitors
Permission design will be compared closely across agents.

What to watch

  1. Any joint technical postmortem with Aten.
  2. Patches or bug bounty payouts tied to notification or Messages paths.
  3. Apple's Full Disk Access changes and their effect on agents.

FAQ

What did Aten claim?

That Muse read his private messages with Full Disk Access turned off.

What does Meta say?

Messages access is opt-in and requires multiple permission steps that cannot be bypassed.

Why was Muse's explanation questioned?

Singleton said the model's explanation about notification syncing was wrong.

Has Apple responded?

Apple later changed Full Disk Access permissions to curb abuse by AI agents.

Read the original

Continue at the source.

TechCrunch

Companies: Meta

More on Meta

All Meta coverage →